There is an understandable tendency within fire safety to assume that more performance must mean operating at the highest level of product classification. Increasingly, however, I am seeing designers being pushed towards products and classifications that may go beyond what the application requires. That raises an important question: are we always specifying for the building or are we sometimes specifying for a particular company’s performance?
This is not an argument for reducing standards; it is the opposite. Good engineering should mean understanding precisely what performance is required, why it is required, and whether there is appropriate evidence to support the proposed solution.

A higher classification does not automatically make a product more appropriate for every application. Specification should begin with the fire strategy and the role the product is expected to perform within it. From there, designers can consider the required classification, supporting construction, tested installation method, available evidence and practical coordination with other building services.
In simple terms: fire strategy + application + classification + evidence + installation + coordination. All six matter. Overspecification can introduce unnecessary cost and complexity, but my greater concern is that it risks shifting attention away from the fundamentals.
A product with an enhanced classification still needs to be suitable for the specific wall, floor, duct arrangement and installation condition for which it is being used or installed.
“Don’t start with the product. Start with what the building needs the product to do.”
For experienced consultants, much of this will already be embedded within established specification processes. But as our industry rightly places greater emphasis on competence and evidence-based decision-making, we should also be confident enough to ask why a particular level of performance is being requested.
The principle I come back to is a simple one: Don’t start with the product. Start with what the building needs the product to do. That is the foundation of good specification.
This article was written by David Fitzpatrick, Managing Director at BSB, for the CIBSE Journal October 26